The median home value in Fishers Island, NY is $695,760.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $490,000.
The national median home value is $308,980.
The average price of homes sold in Fishers Island, NY is $695,760.
Approximately 9% of Fishers Island homes are owned,
compared to 10% rented, while
81% are vacant.
Fishers Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you like to see a property, contact Fishers Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Learn more about Fishers Island.
We were unable to find listings in Fishers Island, NY
Welcome to this delightful 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath Cape nestled on an open lot with picturesque surroundings. Upon entry, you are greeted by a cozy living room featuring gleaming hardwood floors and a wood-burning fireplace, perfect for chilly evenings. The living room flows seamlessly into a bright dining area, ideal for entertaining. The updated kitchen boasts a center island, a beautiful bay window, stainless steel appliances, and easy access to a spacious deck, where you can enjoy outdoor dining with a view. The main level also includes a bedroom, office/sunroom, laundry and a half bath, offering convenience and flexibility. Upstairs, the primary bedroom awaits with beautiful water views, along with a second generously sized bedroom and a full bath. With its blend of comfort and style this home is a perfect retreat for those seeking a tranquil yet convenient lifestyle. Located in Noank, just outside of Historic Village of Noank and downtown Mystic!
This unique home is a mid-century modern masterpiece offering 4100 sq.ft. of single level living on 1.63 acres with seasonal waterviews! A short walk to beaches, this special home has 5BDRS, 4 1/2baths, a large formal living room, a den with FP, full wet bar, sliders to the deck & stereo system with speakers throughout the house. Also, an expansive kitchen w/granite counters, new D/W, sub zero refrigerator, double ovens, electric cooktop range, ice maker, extra freezer. Large dining room,& MBR suite w/luxurious seamless glass shower- all perfect for entertaining and/or short-term rentals! Partially finished lower level studded & plumbed for 4 room layout of potential 2 room in-law apt. w/bath, plus pool room, and kitchen/laundry room. Also in basement a sauna, walk-in cedar closet, wine cellar, & 13 zone heating system new in 2019. Central air, loads of storage, deck, 3 bay garage w/storage, tennis court, rolling lawn w/2 massive copper beach trees. The period architecture is accented by an impressive array of antiques & artwork. A special property with too many amenities to list! SELLER FINANCING AVAILABLE. Come and be part of the exciting New London lifestyle with great dining,boating, shopping, history, and the opportunities of the Coast Guard Academy, Connecticut College, Mitchell College, General Dynamics, Pfizer, etc AND half way between Boston & New York City and minutes from Mystic Ct. attractions.
Enjoy the luxuries of walking to the beach, kayaking on Alewife Cove, and taking a walk throughout the neighborhood. This is a move-in ready 3BR/1.5BA Cape. In the last 5 years, the kitchen has been updated with new cabinets, granite counters, and all new appliances. New roof, water tank, and furnace. The main floor bathroom has been renovated. LL has a semi-finished basement with a half bath and laundry area. There is a lot of room in this Cape for your enjoyment.
Just blocks away from beautiful beaches, this oversized raised ranch boasts 5 bedrooms and 4 full baths, offering ample space for a growing family, hosting guests or renting to summer beach goers. The main level offers a large kitchen with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, ample cabinet space, a dining room and large living room with fireplace, perfect for entertaining family and friends. The primary ensuite offers a fireplace and a walk-in closet, customizable to build out, for the closet of your dreams in an expansive 13' 6" x 7' dedicated space. Located just minutes from the beach, this property offers endless possibilities - whether you're looking for a family home, rental investment opportunity, or vacation retreat. Don't miss out on this rare find in New London, close to General Dynamics/EB, Lawrence and Memorial hospital, Mitchell College, Pequot Point Beach and Ocean Beach.
This former 2 family was completely rebuilt and converted to a single family home in 2023. Excepting some framing, everything is new from completion date in 2023. Open floorplan, 3 BDRS & 2 baths on a .31 acre cleared, level, fenced lot with city H2O & sewer. Laminate flooring throughout, fully applianced including D/W and W/D. Full basement w/ FP for future buildout.(curtain drain needed). OWNER FINANCING preferred (min.10% down payment, all other terms negotiable) or rent w/option to buy or just rent at $3250 a month.
Back on the market due to buyer changing their mind. Welcome to 26 Shepard St, Groton! This charming 3-bedroom home has been thoughtfully updated and meticulously maintained, offering a cozy yet spacious environment. Nestled on a desirable corner lot, the home features a lovely side yard adorned with a privacy-friendly fence of arborvitae, adding both beauty and a little privacy. Inside, the main floor offers convenience with 3 bedrooms and a full bath, a large living room, and an open dining room that invites warm gatherings. The walk-up attic presents an ideal opportunity for expansion, while the lower level includes a recreational area and a workshop, adding versatile space for hobbies or projects. Relax on the covered front porch and take in the peaceful surroundings. Recent updates within the last 10 years include a new roof and gutters, glass storm doors on both front and back, a picture window with casements, a new oil furnace and oil tank, wall AC, vinyl siding, a Bilco door, and chimney improvements (including a stainless steel liner with cap and a new crown with repointing). Conveniently located near EB/general dynamics, Pfizer, USCGA & the naval base. Don't miss the chance to make this beautifully cared-for home your own!
Welcome to Harbour House Condominiums! This charming 1-bedroom, ranch-style unit is conveniently located on the first floor, street-side of a waterfront building. Residents can relax on the expansive pool deck overlooking the river, where you can watch boats, submarines, and ferries glide by. Take a dip in the pool or access the Association Dock (available for an additional cost on a first-come, first-served basis) for boating or kayaking. Association fee include HEAT, HOT WATER, WATER, and SEWER, offering a hassle-free living experience. With no outdoor maintenance required, you can move in and immediately enjoy the comfort and convenience of this beautiful property. Located near the ferry terminal, train station, and major highways, Harbour House ensures seamless connectivity to neighboring cities. Walk to prominent employers such as General Dynamics Electric Boat and Lawrence & Memorial Hospital or explore the variety of nearby dining options within walking distance and beyond.
Discover the best of comfort and convenience with this inviting Colonial, offering 3-4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and a modern layout perfect for both relaxation and entertaining. Just a short walk to Electric Boat, this home is ideally located in the heart of Groton City. As you step into the mudroom, you'll find abundant storage for coats and shoes, seamlessly leading into bright, open living spaces. The spacious dining area connects effortlessly to a cozy living room and a large, well-appointed kitchen-perfect for cooking and gathering alike. The first floor features a versatile flex room with its own private deck access and a full bath, ideal as a guest suite, home office, or main-level bedroom. Outside, there is great space for entertaining, gardening, or simply unwinding, with convenient storage space below the deck. Upstairs, you'll find an expansive primary suite featuring its own private bath two additional bedrooms, and a full bath with laundry hookups. In 2016, this home was remodeled from top-to-bottom with upgrades like a new roof, siding, windows, and an efficient heating system. This home has everything you need to settle in comfortably and start creating new memories. Make it yours in time to enjoy the holidays in your beautiful new home!
Welcome to a true gem in one of Groton's most prestigious neighborhoods! This charming raised ranch offers both promise and potential, making it an ideal canvas for your dream home. With 2 cozy bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, and over 1,500 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, this property is perfect for both relaxing and entertaining. The partially finished basement is a standout feature, providing extra room to grow. Imagine cozy evenings in the family room, complete with a fireplace that adds warmth and character. There's also an additional room that could easily become a third bedroom or a quiet office-whatever suits your needs. Plus, a convenient half bathroom and a walk-out to the patio area under the deck enhance the home's functionality and outdoor appeal. If you're looking to customize your space, this property offers a rare opportunity to be part of an upscale community while making it your own. Don't miss out on this unique find!
Enjoy the ease of one-floor living in this completely updated 4 bedroom 2-bathroom ranch in the sought-after Great Neck area-just minutes to the Long Island sound and many amenities. The property has been completely updated with high-end finishes, new sheetrock, flooring, roof, siding, doors, light fixtures and all new appliances. An on-demand water heater and propane furnace complete this move-in-ready home. Off the kitchen step out to the new deck that leads to the paver patio area. This property is now complete with a new 600sq ft climate-controlled recreation room with multifaceted uses including Gameroom, home office or business a hobbyist dream, or a fun relaxing space to entertain. There is an option to purchase fully Furnished. Start the new year in this luxurious property.
**HEAT AND HOT WATER INCLUDED** Fantastically well kept condo, with breathtaking views of the Thames River. This unit packs a punch; offering 2 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Additionally, the property boasts a gym, private storage area, and screening room. Outside, there is a dingy dock and beach area. This prime location is walking distance to dining, shopping, beaches, parks, medical facilities, etc. It is also conveniently located to all major highways. This unit and property are a must see.
Open House:
Saturday, 1/18 11:30-1:30PM
This charming 1890 Colonial features approximately 1964 square feet of living space with four to five bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The interior has a very nice neutral color palette, an abundance of natural light a spacious layout and beautiful wood floors throughout. The remodeled kitchen is very well-appointed, featuring ample counterspace and cabinets, center island, and stunning solid surface counter tops. The formal dining room is large and inviting, The living room showcases a charming brick fireplace and the family room features a woodstove, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere for chilly days and nights. The primary bedroom is generously sized, flooded with natural light and provides a full bathroom/ensuite. The additional three bedrooms are also upstairs. Stepping outside enjoy the large deck, fish pond, perfect spaces for outdoor relaxation and entertaining. The home sits on a wonderful half acre lot and boasts plenty of beautiful lush landscaping surrounding the property enhances the overall character and curb appeal of this coastal dwelling. Situated in the quaint coast town of Waterford a short distance to beaches and parks offering the residents an opportunity to enjoy the peaceful and picturesque location. The combination of the enticing beach vibe, the charming farmhouse aesthetic and the comfortable, well-appointed interior make this a property an ideal choice for those seeking a serene living experience.
Corner lot Split Level. 3 BR, 1.1 baths, LR with wood burning fireplace and woodstove insert. Fully fenced rear yard. Bel Aire Park and Mystic Magnet School within walking distance. 1.2 miles to Downtown Mystic shops, restaurants and bascule bridge. Full house solar panels about 5 years in to a 20 year lease @ approximately $65 per month.
Open House:
Saturday, 1/18 12:00-2:00PM
Beautiful Newly Renovated 3 Bedroom 2 Full Bath home nestled on .26 Acres just a few miles from Historic Downtown Mystic. Move right in! New Kitchen, Appliances, Fixtures, Flooring, Paint, Hardware and more! Second floor deck off Dining Room -Living Room. Oil Fired Heating System and Central Air Conditioning. 7 New Windows in the process of being installed. Truly move-in condition. Lovely level lot surrounded by mature arborvitae trees. Serviced by municipal water and sewer utilities. Convenient Location just a short distance to I-95 and Historic Downtown Mystic! Immediate Occupancy. Broker-Owner.
Looking for a great space for extended family or in-home office. This home has lots of updates and lots of original charm. First floor with updated kitchen, living / office space, full bath and 2 additional rooms with a ramp off the rear entrance and a wonderful front porch and sunroom room to enjoy. Second floor is spacious, 2 bedrooms, living room, sun room, full bath and eat-in kitchen. Private entry is off the sun room. PLUS a third floor additional space and views of the Thames River and July Fireworks! This versatile floor plan has numerous possibilities. Natural gas, central air (on the first floor), 2 car detached garage was re-built with 3 new walls and roof, full basement. Central Air on the first floor, heat exchanger replaced. Handicap ramp at rear entrance. Short walk to the river, marinas, restaurants, short ride to Ocean Beach. Floor plans with room sizes are viewable. FHA financing welcome.
Unique Mid-century style- Fully renovated in 2024 - mobile home in Mystic! Offering an open floor plan, 2 bedrooms, 1 bath. The seller is open to turning the deck-patio into a 3rd bedroom, if need it. Updates include new electrical, new plumbing, new insulation, new sheetrock and more. Brand New Kitchen, SS appliances, Gas Stove, spacious living room with a flat TV and fireplace. New laminated flooring throughout the home. Mini splits for heating and cooling. The remodeled bathroom offers a walk-in tiled shower and laundry area, washer and dryer been included. This home sits on leased land. This mobile home cannot be rented. Owner occupants only. Pets are welcome. Ready to move in!!! Quick drive to i95, Mystic Seaport and Olde Mistick Village, ten minutes from Electric Boat. Refrigerator, washing and dryer will be installed this week
Two Single family homes on one property! Must be sold as one. Asking price for both homes combined is $399,000. 311 Ocean boasts all the original details of a home built in 1900. The majority of the home has all original picture frame hardwood floors, original trim and beautiful built-ins. Bring your tools to bring this beautiful home back to life! Situated to the rear of the property is 309 Ocean, also with all original hardwood floors along with other historical home details. The property includes an expansive yard and a pad that a garage can be rebuilt on using the same footprint. This unique property provides so many options for potential buyers. Conveniently located to amenities, the hospital and Electric Boat. Both homes are being sold 'as is" Cash and conventional only. 309 Ocean MLS# 24063032
Two Single family homes on one property! Must be sold as one. Asking price for both homes combined is $399,000. 311 Ocean boasts all the original details of a home built in 1900. The majority of the home has all original picture frame hardwood floors, original trim and beautiful built-ins. Bring your tools to bring this beautiful home back to life! Situated to the rear of the property is 309 Ocean, also with all original hardwood floors along with other historical home details. The property includes an expansive yard and a pad that a garage can be rebuilt on using the same footprint. This unique property provides so many options for potential buyers. Conveniently located to amenities, the hospital and Electric Boat. Both homes are being sold 'as is" Cash and conventional only. 309 Ocean MLS# 24063032
Experience luxurious living in this light-filled penthouse unit at the iconic Spool Mill. With breathtaking views of the Mystic River and vibrant downtown, this unique space combines historic charm with modern elegance. Enjoy high ceilings and an abundance of natural light throughout the open-concept living area. Recently updated, the kitchen features sleek countertops, stainless steel appliances, and ample storage-perfect for culinary enthusiasts. Crown moldings and original architectural elements showcase the unit's historic character. Retreat to a generously sized primary suite complete with stunning river views and an en-suite bath for ultimate relaxation. Beautiful hardwood flooring adds warmth and charm to every room. Just a short walk to an array of restaurants, shops, and museums, immerse yourself in the vibrant culture of Mystic. Don't miss the chance to own this exceptional penthouse in one of Connecticut's most charming towns.
Experience luxurious living in this light-filled 2 bed, 2 bath unit at the iconic Spool Mill. With breathtaking northern views of the Mystic River and vibrant downtown, this unique space combines historic charm with modern elegance. Enjoy high ceilings and an abundance of natural light throughout the open-concept living area. The kitchen features sleek countertops, stainless steel appliances, and open concept onto the main living room. Relax to a generously sized primary suite complete with stunning river views and an en-suite bath for ultimate relaxation. Second bedroom or home office with full bathroom located on the opposite side of the unit. Beautiful hardwood flooring adds warmth and charm to every room. Just a short walk to an array of restaurants, shops, and museums, immerse yourself in the vibrant culture of Mystic. Don't miss the chance to own this exceptional penthouse in one of Connecticut's most charming towns.
MOVE IN 2025 - Two Bedrooms, two full baths, two-car garage. SOUGHT AFTER one-floor living with 1,996 square feet. A large primary bedroom with a walk-in closet and primary bath is perfect after a long day. A second bedroom makes this convenient for one-floor living. A vaulted ceiling family room is impressive for gatherings with an open dining room and a modern kitchen which includes Frigidaire stainless steel appliances including an induction range, vented chimney hood, in-island microwave, dishwasher, and garbage disposal. A study is perfect for working from home or enjoying quiet This single-family luxury home community will feature 42 homes. Located in the Village of Pawcatuck, within walking distance to the Pawcatuck River, minutes to downtown Westerly, and surrounded by an abundance of beautiful beaches, golf courses, and vineyards. Enjoy this low-maintenance community with a pavilion gathering area. his home will meet the extraordinary levels of excellence in energy and performance specified by the DOE's Zero Energy Ready and Indoor airPLUS certifications. You can enjoy an independently inspected home with cutting-edge features that ensure unparalleled comfort and long-lasting durability. Our homes boast combustion-free water heating and space conditioning, and rapid hot water delivery through an on-demand recirculation loop.
TO BE BUILT ROOSEVELT with four bedrooms, 4 bath, 2 car attached garage. Enjoy the spacious family and dining room and the kitchen featuring granite countertops, tile backsplash, garbage disposal, and full overlay cabinets with soft-close doors and drawers. The Enclave at Barn Island is nestled in the charming New England shoreline. HOA community includes lawn care, landscaping, snow removal, trash pickup, a covered mail kiosk, and a pavilion with community grills and a fire pit. It is located in the Village of Pawcatuck within walking distance to Hall Cove and surrounded by an abundance of beautiful beaches, golf courses, and vineyards for year-round enjoyment. This home will meet the extraordinary levels of excellence in energy and performance specified by the DOE's Zero Energy Ready and Indoor airPLUS certification. Our homes boast combustion-free water heating and space conditioning, rapid hot water delivery through an on-demand recirculation loop.
LINCOLN FARMHOUSE -NOW BUILDING. MOVE IN READY WINTER 2025 - Two Bedrooms, two full baths, two-car garage. SOUGHT AFTER one-floor living with 1,996 square feet. A large primary bedroom with a walk-in closet and primary bath is perfect after a long day. A second bedroom makes this convenient for one-floor living. A vaulted ceiling family room is impressive for gatherings with an open dining room and a modern kitchen which includes Frigidaire stainless steel appliances including an induction range, vented chimney hood, in-island microwave, dishwasher, and garbage disposal. A study is perfect for working from home or enjoying quiet This single-family luxury home community will feature 42 homes. Located in the Village of Pawcatuck, within walking distance to the Pawcatuck River, minutes to downtown Westerly, and surrounded by an abundance of beautiful beaches, golf courses, and vineyards. Enjoy this low-maintenance community with a pavilion gathering area. his home will meet the extraordinary levels of excellence in energy and performance specified by the DOE's Zero Energy Ready and Indoor airPLUS certifications. You can enjoy an independently inspected home with cutting-edge features that ensure unparalleled comfort and long-lasting durability. Our homes boast combustion-free water heating and space conditioning, and rapid hot water delivery through an on-demand recirculation loop.
Pleasure Beach Gem!! Discover coastal charm in this 3-bedroom cottage nestled in a coveted Waterford neighborhood, mere steps from two beautiful beaches. Each room in this inviting home offers stunning water views, ensuring a serene backdrop to your daily life. Ideal for beach lovers and those seeking a tranquil retreat, this property promises a lifestyle filled with gentle sea breezes and the soothing sounds of the shore. Experience the joy of seaside living in a home where every day is a beach day.
Move into one of the four Like New Mint-Move in Condition Rental Units. First Floor offers 3, 1Br/1Ba Efficiency Units and Second Floor offers a beautiful Furnished 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Unit with all high end furnishings and fixtures. Highly desirable 10 Car Private Parking Lot in rear of property. 3,577 Square Feet nestled on .17 Acres. This amazing property is Serviced by Municipal Water and Sewer, each unit has a propane heating/cooling system. This property is located in the LS-5 Commercial Zone and steps to Downtown Mystic, Deep Water Marinas, Fine Dining and Mystic Train Station. Building has a 15 exterior ADT surveillance camera system. ADT alarm system upstairs. Live upstairs as a primary or vacation home and rent the 3 units below, or, Rent all units short term or long term - Many uses. Excellent income potential, location, condition and parking. All high end furnishings and fixtures in the 3BR/2BA unit on second floor including a Wolf Stove and Sub Zero Refrigerator. All units have surround sound in every room. Live a Dream in Beautiful Mystic, CT! Excellent Location and Investment. Upstairs Apartment has it's own Laundry Room. The 3 Bottom units share a common laundry outside of property. Second Floor 3BR unit is fully furnished. 3 First Floor units are not furnished. Efficiency units square footage is approximate.
© 2025 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC.
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered marks of HomeServices of America, Inc. ®
Equal Housing Opportunity.
Website designed by Constellation1, a division of Constellation Web Solutions, Inc.